Professional Home Remodel Contractors vs. Handymen – 7 Key Differences

Professional home remodel contractors handle larger projects that require permits, design planning, and licensed expertise, ensuring structural integrity and code compliance.

Handymen typically manage smaller repairs or maintenance tasks that don’t involve major construction or renovations.

Did you know that Americans spend thousands of dollars every year on home maintenance, according to American Home Shield?

While becoming a homeowner is the dream for many in the United States, it can also be frustrating to have to deal with issues that require time and money to fix.

Home improvement decisions become even more complex when you must decide between a contractor vs handyman, and who can effectively get the job done.

This article explores the key distinctions between the two, so you can make an informed choice next time you need assistance with your home.

1. Scope of Work

Contractors tend to focus on larger projects, such as remodeling an entire room or section of the home.

Handymen usually fix smaller issues and make minor repairs, like replacing a water heater or a broken light switch.

While contractors can fix minor issues while completing their main job, handymen usually are not qualified to perform the same types of tasks as general contractors.

2. Regulations

The types of projects that contractors work on typically require a permit process that follows area codes and regulations.

Homeowners must often go through official processes and documentation to ensure that all renovations are up to code.

Since handymen focus on smaller tasks, most of their responsibilities do not require permits or extensive regulations. 

3. Insurance and Liability

Due to the nature of their work, contracting companies must carry liability insurance.

This type of insurance protects the contractor from liability in case of harm or bodily injury while on the job site.

The cost of insurance policies varies based on the level of coverage needed and the number of employees covered under the plan.

Handymen can also have liability insurance, but it is not required.

With the nature of their jobs, it may not be worth it for a handyman to have liability insurance, especially if the repairs they usually make carry little to no risk. 

4. Project Management

Contracting companies typically work with a team to complete their projects.

Teams often have a lead contractor who functions as the project manager, dictating the number of employees they will need at any given time, along with the timeline and expertise needed.

Most of the time, handymen function independently, since they usually work on smaller jobs.

Repairs typically take a few hours to a few days, so there is not a drawn-out process that requires a timeline or management plan.

5. Quality of Work

Both handymen and general contractors can produce high-quality work.

However, a handyman’s work is shown in how well they fix general repairs and conduct maintenance on your property.

A general contracting company shines in the polished results of a full remodel.

For instance, a handyman may unclog a toilet or a pipeline in the bathroom, while a professional home remodel contractor would conduct a full-scale bathroom remodel, complete with new appliances, tile, and more.

6. Cost

General contractors are almost always more expensive than handymen, but the cost discrepancy relies on the type of project being completed.

Small repairs by a handyman inherently cost less because of the lack of time and materials.

If you are working with a contractor company, you will likely pay a lot more because of the extent of the renovation required.

For example, a handyman may fix a garbage disposal in your kitchen, while a contracting company would replace the entire sink and counter area. 

7. Time Commitment

Handymen can usually complete assigned tasks in a small timeframe, typically a few hours to a few days.

General contractors work on extensive projects that require detailed timelines, sometimes spanning weeks or even months.

A handyman might stop by briefly to make a repair, while a contractor will have a plan and a designated time frame.

Before your project begins, your contractor will likely review the timeline with you so you are aware of exactly how long the project will take.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can Handymen Work on Home Remodels?

Yes, handymen can work on home remodels.

A handyman may have the necessary qualifications to also serve as a contractor.

Many handymen get paid per job, rather than per hour, so fixing small issues for clients may be a profitable side hustle.

If there are small issues with your home remodel, a handyman may be able to remedy them without a call to the general contractor.

However, it is important to exercise caution in this regard.

How Can I Find a Reputable Contractor or Handyman?

The internet is a fantastic resource for locating reputable professionals to care for your home.

Sites like Yelp and Google Reviews offer unbiased ratings and feedback for local businesses.

You can filter feedback or ratings based on keywords or stars, narrowing down your choices.

Ask around your neighborhood to see if any of your fellow homeowners know people personally.

You may receive a discounted rate through the referral, and the handyman or contractor may also be familiar with the layout of your home, which can simplify the task at hand.

What Are Some of the Benefits of Hiring Contractors?

There are many distinctive benefits to hiring contractors over handymen.

They include:

• A set time frame for the project and guaranteed hours
• Professional expertise and certifications
• A team of experts to help when needed

The Difference Between Professional Home Remodel Contractors and Handymen

Now that you understand the key differences between professional home remodel contractors and handymen, you can make an informed decision for your next home renovation project.

With this guide, it will be easy to determine which type of professional you need and the scope and quality of work involved.

At Mariano & Co., we focus on cultivating long-term clients who can trust the quality and level of service that we provide.

Our team of dedicated professionals has been working on home remodeling projects since 2009.

Are you ready to see the Mariano & Co. difference?

Reach out to us today to learn more about the services we offer.

We can’t wait to meet you!

---

Expert Split Level Home Kitchen Remodel Services
Transform your split-level home with Mariano & Co., the experts in modern kitchen remodeling. Our skilled team blends design innovation, functionality, and craftsmanship to create beautiful, seamless kitchen spaces tailored to your home’s layout and lifestyle. Whether you’re updating for style, space, or flow, we bring your vision to life with precision and care.
Call (480) 287-4096 or request a consultation online to start your split-level kitchen remodel today!